Evaluation of Compensation for Moral Damage Caused by Unlawful Criminal Prosecution

Alla Vereshchagina

doi:doi:10.12737/14382

Evaluation of Compensation for Moral Damage Caused by Unlawful Criminal Prosecution

Published в Journal of Russian Law · Volume 3, Issue 11, 2015 · Pages 0–0 · Rubrics: Procedural Law

DOI 10.12737/14382

Received: 02.11.2015 Accepted: 11.11.2015 Published: 11.11.2015 Language of publication: RUS

Authors

Alla Vereshchagina

ABSTRACT

The article is devoted to the problem of determining and proving the amount of compensation for moral damage, caused by unlawful criminal prosecution. Special attention is paid to the practice of proving the damage in court decisions. The author provides classification of circumstances, that need to be proved upon trial, and separates these circumstances into prejudicial and individual peculiarities of the victim that require proof, as well as depth and degree of the victim’s physical and moral suffering. This approach allows revealing shortcomings of proving. When courts pass their judgments in relation to this category of acts, they rarely assess the victim’s individuality. Refusal to prove the depth and degree of moral damage and to take personal individuality into account results in oversimplified and unmotivated decisions. The author comes to the conclusion that the current court practice is in conflict with the civil procedural code. In the author’s opinion, it is necessary to create rules for determining the amount of moral damage and carrying out mandatory examinations for assessing the victim’s individual characteristics.

KEYWORDS

Civil law civil procedure rehabilitation unlawful criminal prosecution moral damage court judgment proving of compensation amount.

Information References

Authors:

Type:

Article

Pages:

from 0 to 0

Status:

Published

Language:

Russian

Keywords:

Civil law, civil procedure, rehabilitation, unlawful criminal prosecution, moral damage, court judgment, proving of compensation amount.

References

1. Vereshchagina A. V. O faktorakh, vliyayushchikh na razmer kompensatsii moral´nogo vreda, prichinennogo nezakonnymi deystviyami doznavatelya, sledovatelya, prokurora i suda v khode osushchestvleniya ugolovnogo sudoproizvodstva (na materialakh sudebnoy praktiki). Gosudarstvo i pravo. 2013. № 4.

2. Vladimirova V. V. Kompensatsiya moral´nogo vreda - mera reabilitatsii poterpevshego v rossiyskom ugolovnom protsesse. M., 2007.

3. Dmitrieva O. V. Nekotorye problemy instituta kompensatsii moral´nogo vreda. Vestnik Voronezhskogo instituta MVD. 2010. № 1.

4. Zeyts A. Vozmeshchenie moral´nogo vreda. Ezhenedel´nik sovetskoy yustitsii. 1927. № 47.

5. Karmanova E. V. Kompensatsiya moral´nogo vreda: problema opredeleniya razmera. VUZ. XXI vek. 2013. № 1.

6. Pereverzev A. S., Rzaev R. R. Kompensatsiya moral´nogo vreda (istoriko-pravovoy aspekt). Vestnik Essentukskogo instituta upravleniya, biznesa i prava. 2010. № 3.

7. Semykin V. V. Ponyatie moral´nogo vreda v teorii grazhdanskogo prava i v rossiyskom zakonodatel´stve. Vestnik MGOU. Seriya «Yurisprudentsiya». 2013. № 2.

8. Semykin V. V. Primenenie sudeyskogo usmotreniya pri razreshenii del o kompensatsii moral´nogo vreda. Vestnik MGOU. Seriya «Yurisprudentsiya». 2013. № 3.

9. Sisak´yan A. K. Razvitie zakonodatel´stva i nauchnykh predstavleniy o kompensatsii moral´nogo vreda v sovetskiy period. Vestnik Chelyabinskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Pravo. 2011. № 29.

10. Tabunshchikov A. T. Kompensatsiya moral´nogo vreda v Rossii i za rubezhom: mnogoaspektnost´ problemy. Nauchnye vedomosti Belgorodskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriya «Filosofiya, sotsiologiya, pravo». 2009. T. 57. № 7.

11. Uskov V. Kak kompensirovat´ moral´nyy vred bogatomu i bednomu?. Rossiyskaya yustitsiya. 2000. № 12.

12. Utevskiy B. Vozmeshchenie neimushchestvennogo vreda kak mera sotsial´noy zashchity. Ezhenedel´nik sovetskoy yustitsii. 1927. № 35.

13. Fleyshits E. A. Obyazatel´stva iz prichineniya vreda i neosnovatel´nogo obogashcheniya. M., 1951.

14. Khanina K. V. Kompensatsiya moral´nogo vreda kak sposob zashchity nematerial´nykh blag i sub´´ektivnykh grazhdanskikh prav. Vestnik RUDN. Seriya «Yuridicheskie nauki». 2000. № 2.

15. Chumanov A. V., Tsvetkova A. N. Otsenka moral´nogo vreda ekspertnym putem. Pravovaya politika i pravovaya zhizn´. 2003. № 3.

16. Erdelevskiy A. M. Kompensatsiya moral´nogo vreda: analiz i kommentariy zakonodatel´stva i sudebnoy praktiki. 3-e izd. M., 2004.

17. ErdelevskiyA. M. Kompensatsiya moral´nogo vreda. M., 1996.

18. Erdelevskiy A. M. Moral´nyy vred i kompensatsiya za stradaniya. M., 1998.

Evaluation of Compensation for Moral Damage Caused by Unlawful Criminal Prosecution

Confirmation

Регистрация